Protecting Scientific Integrity Starts at the Bargaining Table

EPA scientists won integrity protections in their union contract. The agency canceled the contract before punishing dissent.

Read on Medium

By Jennifer Dorning, President, Department for Professional Employees, AFL-CIO

Scientists, engineers, and other experts serve the public best when they can follow the evidence, share what they find, and speak up when something goes wrong. Over the past two years, the administration has made that harder, cutting scientific staff and adding political review of research grants. Scientists and advocates are now pressing the new Congress to re-establish safeguards against political interference.

The Department for Professional Employees, AFL-CIO (DPE) is proud to stand with our partners in the Coalition for Professional Integrity (CPI) in achieving those safeguards. At one federal agency, scientists won a strong safeguard at the bargaining table, and the administration's move to dismantle it shows why collective bargaining and professional integrity go hand in hand.

Integrity policies are only as strong as their enforcement

For more than fifteen years, federal agencies have adopted scientific integrity policies and channels for reporting interference, but those policies vary widely in strength depending on who’s in office. Unfortunately, the political leaders those policies aim to restrain can rewrite, reinterpret, or ignore them, and the officials who decide complaints usually report to those same political leaders. 

Professional integrity rarely breaks down in one dramatic moment. It erodes when a manager tells a scientist to skip a conference, when a report sits unpublished, when staff learn that speaking up costs a career. As I wrote in Federal News Network last year, the administration was illegally weakening the protections that let federal workers maintain their professional integrity. CPI came together to push back, committed to strengthening civil service protections and upholding union contracts.

Collective bargaining is one of CPI's core principles because it gives scientists a way to fight back. With a union contract, the people who do the work negotiate binding terms. When management violates those terms, workers can take the dispute to a neutral arbitrator instead of leaving it to the managers accused of interference. Scientific societies, professional associations, and good-government groups defend professional standards from the outside. A union contract protects them from the inside.

What a union contract can do: the EPA example

In 2024, American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE) Council 238, which represents about 8,000 EPA employees, won strong scientific integrity protections in its union contract. Article 2 of the agreement aimed to "prevent inappropriate interference in scientific work" and covered any employee who collects, generates, uses, or evaluates scientific data. Under it:

  • Employees who reported scientific misconduct or violations of the agency's integrity policy in good faith were protected from retaliation.

  • Employees could discuss their work at conferences, at meetings, and with the press in their personal capacity, within federal ethics rules.

  • Management had to put denials of scientific conference attendance in writing when employees asked.

  • Changes to key definitions in the agency's scientific integrity policy were subject to negotiation.

  • Like any contract provision, these protections were enforceable through grievance and arbitration.

Why the administration went after the contract first

The strongest evidence that collective bargaining protects scientific integrity comes from the people who wanted it gone.

In March 2025, President Trump issued Executive Order 14251, stripping collective bargaining rights at agencies that employ, by AFGE's estimate, almost 70 percent of federal workers. That June, EPA employees published a Declaration of Dissent warning that administration policies were undermining the agency's mission to protect human health and the environment.

In August 2025, after a federal appeals court allowed the executive order to take effect, EPA terminated its contract with the employees AFGE represents. Only then did it discipline the signers, firing at least 16 and suspending 119 without pay, according to the union's lawsuit. Stripped of their collective bargaining rights, the signers had lost the right to have a neutral arbitrator review that discipline. Council 238 President Justin Chen put it plainly: agency leadership "didn't want to face any accountability" before the Federal Labor Relations Authority or an arbitrator.

The contract's integrity protections stood between EPA's scientists and retaliation.

Losing the contract did not end the fight. AFGE has sued to restore it, and DPE and the labor movement has stood with federal workers and their unions to win back their bargaining rights. In December 2025, the House passed the Protect America's Workforce Act with bipartisan support to overturn the executive order. Even without a contract, the union is still standing up for EPA's scientists.

Why integrity advocates should fight for bargaining rights

Professional integrity means trained judgment drives decisions about the work. Protecting that judgment is one of the main reasons professionals form unions. Through bargaining, union professionals have won protections for scientific and editorial independence, safe staffing and caseload limits, and a say in how new technology is used. A contract can guarantee that professional judgment shapes decisions about patient care, research, or what goes on the air.

For federal scientists and researchers, a contract limits how managers can use assignments, travel approvals, performance reviews, and discipline to pressure them. It also guarantees due process. Managers can still act for good reason, but they must follow fair, consistent procedures, which protects scientists who deliver unwelcome findings from arbitrary punishment.

Interference with science succeeds when people fear that speaking up could cost them their jobs. Contract protections against retaliation make it safer to speak up. A union also gives scientists something no policy can: each other. Of the EPA employees punished for signing the Declaration of Dissent, Chen said, “they are not standing alone.” Scientists can't defend their integrity alone; together, they can.

Bargaining for the public interest

Professionals and their unions have long argued that collective bargaining is a tool for professional autonomy, high standards, and better public service. At the EPA, scientists used it to protect their science, and the agency disciplined them for speaking up only after their contract was gone.

Scientists, their unions, and the public all want a government where experts can follow the evidence and tell the public what they find. Reaching that goal means restoring and strengthening federal workers' collective bargaining rights, so no executive order can erase the protections scientists win at the bargaining table. Anyone who cares about science in government should join that fight.

Next
Next

Professionals Across the Country Organized with DPE Affiliated Unions in 2025